Gill Stannard

Showing posts with label asthma. Show all posts
Showing posts with label asthma. Show all posts

Monday, March 02, 2009

Living with food allergies and intolerances

What is a food allergy?

An allergy is an exaggerated immune system response to something the body believes is foreign. This results in an overproduction of a particular type of immunoglobulin (such as IgE, IgG or IgA) when the person encounters the allergen.

With food allergies it may begin as soon as a person touches (hands, lips etc) the food, resulting in swelling. These types of extreme reactions may cause a shock reaction in the body known as anaphylaxis, where the blood vessels become leaky causing swelling that may block the airways, as well as cause a dangerous drop in blood pressure. This complex and extreme reaction can affect all the major organs in the body and can be fatal. In Australia, these types of allergies are on the increase. The incidence of peanut allergies alone have doubled in the past 9 years.

While anaphylaxis is dramatic and obvious, most reactions we see to the food occur once it has been eaten. These are usually classified as “food intolerance” and in some cases are caused by a lack of enzymes (enzymes are made in the liver and break down the food as part of digestion). Symptoms may include mouth ulcers, digestive pain, bloating, change in bowel habits, eczema, asthma, wheezing, migraines, hives, hayfever, recurrent ear, nose or throat infections or even behavioural changes. Intolerance symptoms may come on within minutes of eating the suspect food or be delayed and take up to 24 hours to become noticeable.

Coeliac “disease” is classified as an intolerance to gluten (the protein found in wheat and other members of the grass family). Contact with gluten causes the absorptive surfaces of the gut (villi) to deflate, causing malabsorption and ultimately nutrient deficiencies, immune problems and other chronic health problems.

While lactose (a reaction to milk sugar) intolerance has been considered to be common for a long time, the diagnosis of an intolerance to fructose (a natural sugar in some fruits and vegetables) is becoming more frequent.

Can you grow out of a food allergy?

In traditional naturopathy we tend to view this issue differently than in conventional medicine. If a child has an “atopic allergy” such as eczema or asthma what we tend to find it that they are allergic for life but the way that allergy is expressed by the body may change. For example, as a baby they may begin with purely digestive symptoms – when they have the food (even via breast milk) they may vomit, have colic, cry or have changes to their bowel. If they continue to be exposed to the allergen, this gut symptoms may be less prominent but the child develops eczema or frequent ear infections. As they get older asthma may develop or frequent colds and sore throats. The symptoms may shift but the body continues to react in some way.

While conventional medicine does not expect a person to “grown out of” coeliac/gluten intolerance or anaphylactic reactions to food, strangely many doctors still perpetuate the myth that children grow out of other food intolerances and allergies as they get older.

There has been some interesting new research desensitsing children with a peanut allergy using peanut flour. It would be helpful to follow the children over the next 5 years once they are “desensitised” to see any other allergic symptoms or chronic health problems emerge.


What are the most common allergenic foods?

This may vary from country to country depending on the diet. In the Western world, the “big eight” are allergies to dairy, wheat, eggs, shellfish/seafood, peanuts, tree nuts, soy and corn.

In Japan, buckwheat allergies are common, while corn is more common in North America.

Common intolerances to foods include – milk sugar, milk protein, fructose, salicylates, sulphur, sucrose and citric acid.

How do you get a food allergy or intolerance?

In most cases of allergy you are born with it but specific allergic predispositions or a lack of specific enzymes to break down some components of food, but it may also be acquired from over use of a food or as a result of an infection in the digestive system, when the gut lining is weakened (sometimes referred to as “leaky gut” and larger molecules of food may cross into the blood stream and cause an antibody-antigen reaction.

How do you diagnose a food allergy or intolerance?

There is no irrefutable, reliable form of testing for all food allergies or intolerances. Because an allergic reaction causes an over production of IgE it should be easy to pinpoint but it is not as easy as it seems. There needs to be recent exposure to the allergen to get an accurate result. Further more our diets are more complex now and we can be exposed to hundreds of different types of foods and food additives, each one needs to individually tested. An intolerance is even more challenging to scientifically detect.

Skin prick/IgE/rast tests for foods are commonly used in conventional medicine. This is the done by pricking the skin with a needle or probe and dropping serum containing the allergen into the exposed skin. In naturopathy this form of testing is considered to be notoriously inaccurate for food allergies and intolerances, yielding both false positive and negative reactions.

Elisa/IgG blood tests for food sensitivities are carried out by some labs in Australia but are not covered by Medicare. Apart from this (and ALCAT below) type of testing being not accepted by conventional medicine the biggest potential issues are the lack of labs doing this test in Australia to compare results for accuracy and also the relatively small number of foods that are tested. Most use less than 100 common foods, which are Northern European in source. For example common Australian fish like flathead and flake are not tested.

The Antigen leukocyte cellular antibody test (ALCAT), measures platelet aggregation and changes in white blood cells after mixing whole blood with extracts of foods and chemicals. This is equally as controversial and more expensive than the IgG test but anecdotally the responses are promising and can test a wider range of foods and additives. However I have experienced some major issues with one Melbourne lab and at the current time am not referring clients for this test.

The above two tests can be useful when a person is reacting to a common food that most people tolerate (ie: not one of the “big eight”. For example I have had clients test positive to chicken, lemons and rice.

Traditional forms of diagnosis in naturopathy include an elimination diet, ie: removing suspect foods and reintroducing them one by one to see if a reaction is provoked (sometimes called “fast and challenge) or doing a pulse test. To do an elimination diet, you need to be totally in control of your food and usually cook everything from scratch. This is time consuming and inconvenient but a cheap way to build a list of food suspects. Remember it is not always a single allergen or intolerance that is the problem, often people have multiple food issues.

The Pulse Test – this is purely anecdotal but is an interesting experiment.

1. Take and record your pulse for a full minute before you get out of bed each morning. (Normal resting pulse in adults is between 60 and 80 beats a minute.)
2. Take your pulse again right before you eat any one food that you suspect is an allergen or you'd like to rule out.
3. Take your pulse immediately after eating the food.
4. Don't eat any other foods. Take your pulse again at 30 minutes and at 60 minutes after eating the food in question. Keep a record of the foods you test.

If your pulse is raised by 10-15 (or greater) more beats a minute at any of the three tests the food is considered to by suspect. Retest the next time you eat the food to see if you get the same results.

Living with a food allergy or intolerance

We don’t know why the incidence of childhood food allergies are increasing but we do know that it has doubled in the past nine years in Australia. Most worrying is the rise in serious allergic reactions.

On the last show I covered the five stages of grief and mentioned being challenged to take a suspect food out of your diet can often cause denial, bargaining, anger and even depression. If you are having trouble identifying the foods or implementing a diverse, low allergy diet see an experienced naturopath for help.

Further resources

Building healthy bones: the dairy/calcium myth.

Asthma: including low allergy diets.

Hayfever.

The soy controversy: are soy foods dangerous for boys?

Coeliac “disease": gluten and wheat-free diets.

Study comparing peanut allergies in Jewish children in the UK and Israel: children introduced to peanuts earlier in life had a lower rate of allergy.

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Paracetamol and asthma

In recent weeks new research into a link between paracetamol use and childhood asthma has hit the news. A New Zealand based research team surveying children from 31 countries found a marked increase in asthma in children who were given paracetamol in the first year of life, compared with those who were never given the drug. The study involved 200,000 6-7 year olds and scientists were stunned when they crunched the numbers to find that paracetamol use under the age of one made a child 46% more likely to become an asthmatic.

However, they should not have been that surprised as the link between asthma attacks in adults and paracetamol was clearly demonstrated in a landmark study published eight years ago (Shaheen S et al. Frequent paracetamol use and asthma in adults. Thorax 2000;55:266-270). Initial findings linked weekly paracetamol use with an 80% increase in asthma symptoms, compared with adults who never used the drug.

Panadol, the leading brand of paracetamol made by GSK, is specifically marketed for use in babies from the age of one month. In fact, it is routinely recommended by medical professionals to be used for pain relief concurrently with immunisations. The current Australian immunisation schedule begins at birth for Hepatitis B, with the bulk of the vaccines to be started by two months old (often 5-6 weeks).

Paracetamol is also erroneously spruiked for the prevention of infantile febrile convulsions, which can be a consequence of fevers. The Cochrane Review (considered to be the leader in evidence based medicine) regarding this use of Panadol (et al) concludes, “There is insufficient evidence to show whether paracetamol influenced the risk of febrile convulsions”. Further more the Australian Prescriber is not only convinced that paracetamol is ineffective in preventing febrile convulsions but questioned the need to avoid fevers in the first place. A long held naturopathic and anthroprosophical medicine belief is that fever in children, even to the point of convulsions, may play a role in the of development of the immune system

In naturopathy, we advise all parents to avoid administering any substance other than breast milk to their babies for the first three months of life (or three months after the full term date when born prematurely). This is because the immature liver is not developed enough to process anything other than human milk. Obviously in life threatening circumstances, pharmaceutical drugs are a necessity. In all other cases we would suggest avoiding using any other substance or medicine until three months of age.

Despite its benign reputation, paracetamol is a very dangerous drug due to its potential to cause liver toxicity and ultimately organ failure. Without immediate treatment, a family pack of Panadol could kill the average teenager (in a particularly slow and agonizing way).

While the connection between asthma and paracetamol in both children and adults is not fully understood, the take home message is that all painkillers should be treated with caution for the time being. Even more so if there is any family history of eczema, hayfever or asthma.


Other posts on asthma

2008 Health Trip show on Asthma

Antibiotic use increase the risk of children having asthma.

Food additives

Additives in infant medicines

"Silent reflux" misdiagnosed as asthma

Monday, April 28, 2008

asthma

What is asthma?

With over 2 million Australians being diagnosed with asthma, including up to 1:4 children, we are living in one of the most allergy prone countries in the world.

Asthma is an inflammatory condition of the airways in the lungs. It may feel like a persistent, irritated cough, a tightness in the chest or a distinctive wheezing sound when trying to breathe. This may be caused by a change in air temperature, exercise, dust, pollens, cigarette smoke, a respiratory infection or a wide range of allergens. When triggered, this causes swelling, constriction and the production of thick, sticky mucus that makes breathing, especially exhaling air, very difficult. Most asthma attacks are well managed with preventative (eg: steroids) or acute (eg: Ventolin) drugs but sometimes an asthma attack can be fatal. Because of this, all practitioners take a diagnosis of asthma very seriously.

Can you treat asthma without drugs?

Firstly it is important to actually make sure that someone actually has asthma. This may sound strange but asthma is misdiagnosed in both children and adults at an alarming rate. In kids there has been a tendency to classify most prolonged coughs as asthma.
Associate Professor Colin Robertson from the Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne is also a spokesman for the National Asthma Council of Australia. He says he's spent more time undiagnosing asthma than diagnosing it over the past decade. “Throughout the quarter of last century, there was an amazing awareness campaign for improving the diagnosis of asthma, which has been incredibly effective, and perhaps a bit too effective, so that children with a wide range of respiratory symptoms are having the diagnosis of asthma and not all of them have it.” ABC ’7.30 Report’, 8.4.03


In adults as well as children, common conditions such as 'silent reflux’ (gastrointestinal oesophageal reflux or GORD/GERD) which often triggers coughing after food, coffee, exercising or lying down - may be more likely to be a culprit in a person with no past history or allergies. The cough does not significantly improve on asthma medication, nor develop into serious breathing problems.

With a clear diagnosis of asthma, it would be unusual for a naturopath to tell a client to cease their pharmaceutical drugs. Treatment is generally centred around – decreasing triggers, reducing mucus, improving breathing, increasing immunity and trying to decrease the incidence of respiratory infections.

Can foods cause asthma?

Asthma is typically seen initially in children with a family history of atopic allergies eg: eczema, asthma, hayfever, hives. Often they have a history of eczema or other skin rashes before developing respiratory problems. This may go away when they use topical steroid creams but later it is not unusual for some of these children to present with asthma. Some naturopaths believe that the eczema is the body’s way of trying to get the person to avoid an allergen and when this is dampened down or ‘cured’ with drugs it can express itself in a different way such as asthma or persistent rhinitis. While there is much debate as to whether foods like dairy products or wheat “cause” asthma or produce mucus in the respiratory system, in practice an appropriate low allergy diet does tend to provide good results.

In my experience, when all dairy foods (including ‘hidden’ dairy in some processed foods) are removed from the diet long term, it can improve most allergic respiratory conditions. While other triggers still abound – such as pollens and changes in air temperature, food is the one thing we can control most of all.

Other things we can’t always control that have been linked to developing asthma and other allergies include: caesarean birth, antibiotics in the first 6 months of life, being bottle rather than breast fed, air pollution, passive smoking or being overweight.

Nutrients for asthma

A number of studies have shown a connection between low nutrition, especially antioxidants such as Vitamins E, A and C and asthma. These nutrients tend to have anti-inflammatory actions, so too does fish oil. There is some evidence that magnesium may be implicated in asthma.

Try to avoid polyunsaturated vegetable oils, margarine, vegetable shortening, all partially hydrogenated oils that might contain trans-fatty acids and deep-fried foods, due to their ability to provoke inflammation. Use anti-inflammatory herbs like ginger and turmeric.

Typically, a low allergy diet for asthma is a good starting place. This is one without wheat, dairy, soy, corn (including high fructose corn syrup), eggs, nuts and all additives. Include alternative sources of calcium such as seeds (eg tahini), beans, and edible fish bones (eg: in canned salmon and sardines, also high in good oils). Ideally most food is cooked from scratch, as processed food even when it doesn’t contain suspected allergens, is low in nutrition. Increase the amounts of seasonal fruits and vegetables, grains such as quinoa, brown rice, oats and barley and other wholefoods like beans and lentils.

After 3-6 weeks, introduce a new food group, one at a time, each week and see if there is any worsening in the asthma. Record symptoms on a chart, peak flow readings and how often acute medication is needed.

Alternative treatments for asthma

Both Western and Chinese herbal medicines are frequently used for asthma. I use herbs like elecampane, hyssop and sundew to strengthen the lungs, as well as immune stimulants and nervous system tonics as required depending on the individual. Unfortunately in Australia some strong but effective herbs like lobelia and ephedra are no longer available to be prescribed by herbalists.

There are potentially issues with the contamination and adulteration of some Chinese medicines bought overseas or in Australia. These have included heavy metals or the inclusion of non-disclosed pharmaceutical drugs. This is less likely to occur if you are given raw herbs to decoct rather than pre-made tablets or powders.

Manual treatments – including osteopathy, chiropractic and remedial massage can often help if the diaphragm is tight of other musculo-skeletal problems are apparent.

Buteyko technique - has some of the most promising results for asthma management. This is a breathing technique that needs to be taught by a qualified instructor. I would thoroughly recommend every asthmatic to give it a go.

Appropriate exercise: There is a good reason why so many of our gold medal winning swimmers began their life as asthmatics. While exercise can be a trigger for asthma attacks, swimming is largely beneficial, though preferably in an outdoor, non-chlorinated pool. Yoga and chi-gong can also be useful.

Other common asthma triggers

Analgesic drugs, such as aspirin and nsaids, panadol is often a safer choice.

Cleaning products especially aerosol and spray based ones. White vinegar and bicarbonate of soda are effective cleaners and much safer for asthmatics.

Cockroaches mould and dust mites. This offers some solutions.

Cats and dogs are controversial. Though an obvious trigger for some, growing up in a home with pets, such as in this study looking at cats, can also reduce your chances of becoming an asthmatic. And here's a study in support of dogs.

Not taking your asthma seriously. While complementary therapies may reduce your need for medication, doing nothing and not having an action plan is a disaster waiting to happen.

As reminded by a caller on the show - check your heating. Gas heaters, especially those with a pilot light, can provoke asthma in some. Also clean out your ducted heating every year. It costs a little money but is worth it when you see the gunk pulled out of the ducts that you were breathing in.

Update: April 2009. "A low intake of vitamins A and C could raise the risk of asthma, a team which reviewed 40 studies carried out over the past 30 years has said.

A Nottingham University-led team found people with a low intake of vitamin C had a 12% increased risk of asthma, the Thorax journal reported.

For vitamin A the raised risk was less clear cut, the team said, but there was still a significant association." Read more

Monday, February 04, 2008

caffeine - benefits and harms

Caffeine, a xanthine alkaloid, appears in some of our favourite foods and beverages in various forms including coffee, tea (green, black and white), cola, ‘energy’ drinks, cocoa, chocolate, guarana and mate. It is also added to some pharmaceutical drugs and is available in popular over the counter stimulants.

Physiologically, caffeine has a stimulant effect on the body. It increases nerve cell activity in the brain and triggers the pituitary gland to release more adrenaline (also known as epinephrine, the ‘fight or flight’ hormone). Some of the effects include an initial sense of alertness, increased cardiac activity (heart beats faster) and a release of glycogen (stored sugar) giving us an energy boost. The first cup or two of caffeine may have what is perceived as being a positive effect on wellbeing, helping us think more clearly and act faster, those these benefits are reversed with increased intake. If you are already stressed, the added adrenaline will potentiate this state – increasing your chance of panic attacks, palpitations, insomnia, sweating etc.

However – as we are all individuals this can have different effects on us depending on how long it takes to metabolise caffeine, such as age, various medications and health of the liver. For example the half life (how long it takes the body to clear half of the caffeine from the body) in a healthy adult is about 3-4 hours, in a woman taking the oral contraceptive pill that increases to 5-10 hours, while in a pregnant woman it is up to 11 hours. The half life for a baby in utero or a newborn is even higher, so that even on one decent cup of caffeine a day via the mother’s milk the neonate may not have got rid of yesterdays intake fully before today’s hit.

Much of the conjecture as to whether caffeine may be harmful or beneficial comes down to genotype, how your individual blueprint dictates your metabolism of certain drugs. In science speak, it is all to do with your variant of the cytochrome P450 enzymes. Current wisdom deems that it is your variation of this enzyme that effects how you utilise caffeine (CYP1A21A allele are "rapid" caffeine metabolisers, whereas carriers of the variant CYP1A21F are "slow" caffeine metaboliers). For example see this study on caffeine metabolism and heart attack risk.

Interestingly, as caffeine is metabolised in the liver by the cytochrome P450 (enzyme) pathway – so do a number of herbs and drugs. The reason St John’s wort (and other herbs) is contraindicated with a number of pharmaceuticals (including the contraceptive pill, antivirals, anti-rejection drugs and some chemotherapy agents) is due to competing with this same metabolic pathway. Considering the popularity of coffee etc and quantity consumed – should there be a warning label slapped on your latte or cola drink?

Want to know more? Here's a good reference on the chemistry, metabolism and addictiveness of caffeine

Because there are so many variables in the way that caffeine is broken down in the body it could explain why it affects individuals so differently, though tolerance and addiction are also key players in the caffeine picture. This delicious alkaloid has a similar effect on dopamine, one of our ‘happy hormones’, as cocaine and heroin. It also interferes with another chemical, adenosine, which may cause insomnia. With less sleep we wake up ‘needing’ our caffeine hit to get going in the morning – and so the cycle continues.

When we abstain from our daily caffeine hits, the tiredness that many people experience is actually how you felt before – only the drug was masking it. So stopping caffeine doesn’t actually make you any tireder – rather it gets you in touch with where your body is really at. Increasing the amount of water you drink and taking a good multivitamin with at least 50 mg of B6, plus a few early nights should help remedy this.

There has been a flurry of negative studies about caffeine published recently, what is most significant is they overturn previous studies (or assumptions) as to benign or even beneficial effects of caffeine. These include an increase in first trimester miscarriage at even half (200 mg) the presumed ‘safe’ dose and a harmful rise in blood glucose levels in people with diabetes.

While most obstetricians have assured women for years that a caffeine intake equivalent of 3 standard cups of coffee a day in pregnancy will not harm the foetus, (keep in mind it was only a generation or ago that smoking in pregnancy wasn’t considered harmful) a study published this year in The American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology has overturned this assumption. In a well-designed study a mere 200mg (just over one decent cafĂ© cup of coffee) a day was shown to double the chance of miscarriage in the first trimester. This was shown to be even more detrimental in women who had previously had a miscarriage.

Previous studies have also shown a connection between delayed conception (ie: taking longer to get pregnant) and caffeine intake in women. Paradoxically, it may have a positive effect on sperm motility (though I have not cited the study this claim is based on).

The second negative study regarding caffeine to hit the news already this year is in connection with Type 2 diabetes. While previous investigations have suggested that caffeine may be beneficial for those with diabetes, a pilot study in this month’s issue of Diabetes Care, tracks the effects of pure caffeine (versus tea or coffee drinking) on blood sugar levels. On average blood glucose levels rose by 8% after caffeine though after an evening meal this could peak to 26%. While it had a very small sample size, considering that we already know that caffeine triggers the liver to release glycogen, there is compelling evidence that avoiding caffeine of all kinds could help diabetics achieve better control.


Other than ‘helping’ us think and act initially quicker, caffeine appears to assist bronchodilatation – meaning if you are an asthmatic at the beginning of an attack without your inhaler, a strong cup of coffee immediately may bring some relief. There are some studies that coffee drinking may also be protective against Parkinson’s disease.

Don’t forget that all forms of caffeine (even so-called ‘decaf’) can negatively impact on your absorption or utilisation of a variety of nutrients – especially calcium, protein, iron and water soluble vitamins (eg B and C) so keep caffeine consumption away for meal times and supplement taking.

Updates: Here are some other articles on interest on the topic.

Red bull - heart attack in a can?

Coffee psychosis